Key Takeaways

  • CarShield stands out with its diverse, customizable coverage plans tailored to each driver's needs.
  • Acknowledged by the Better Business Bureau, CarShield upholds a strong reputation and customer trust.
  • Given its comprehensive coverage and customer service, CarShield's extended warranty is a smart investment for any car owner.

This post may include affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we'll receive a commission at no extra cost to you. This support helps us maintain and grow our site. Thank you for your support!

If you're in the market for an extended car warranty, you've probably come across CarShield. We’ve taken a closer look and put together an in-depth review.

CarShield offers vehicle service contracts that cover both new and used cars. With a range of plans to choose from, they aim to cater to different budgets and requirements. The transparent pricing and highly-rated customer service reflect CarShield's commitment to customer satisfaction.

Our evaluation focuses on providing you with clear and precise information that will help guide your selection. Keep reading to learn more about CarShield, the plans they offer, and whether it's the right choice for you in terms of pricing, coverage, and reputation. Armed with this knowledge, you'll be better equipped to determine if CarShield is the best warranty provider for your needs.

Table of Contents

CarShield Review: Unbiased Evaluation

We recently explored CarShield's extended auto warranty offerings, and we have to say they provide a great variety of coverage plans. They are undoubtedly an attractive choice for car owners.

Based on what we learned, CarShield earns a 4.6 out of 5 rating, which indicates that many customers have had positive experiences with their services. Their plans offer comprehensive coverage and flexible payment options, and signing up is easy.

We really appreciate CarShield's commitment to customer satisfaction, and we're impressed by its overall reputation. In our experience, CarShield has lived up to its positive reviews and provided us with convenient and reliable vehicle coverage options.

We just can't help but express how much we love CarShield. The friendly, approachable tone evident in their customer service is truly refreshing. The company has not only met but exceeded our expectations with efficient and reliable coverage.

What is CarShield?

CarShield is a company that provides vehicle service contracts, often referred to as extended car warranties. CarShield contracts also often include additional benefits, such as roadside assistance, rental car coverage, and trip interruption services.

CarShield's service contracts are designed to cover the cost of repairs after your vehicle's original manufacturer's warranty has expired. This extended car warranty can cover various components of your car, such as the engine, transmission, etc.

They offer several coverage plans to fit the varying needs of car owners. Each plan has its specific set of features, ensuring a tailored experience for the customers. This is why CarShield customers love using the service too.

Why We Love CarShield

As we explored various car warranty options, we've come to appreciate CarShield for several reasons. The company offers a wide range of coverage plans, making it easy for us to choose a plan that best suits our vehicles and needs.

Furthermore, the user-friendly and transparent services provided by CarShield make it a prime choice for extended car warranty options. In this section, we'll discuss three key features of CarShield that we particularly love.

Flexible Coverage Options

One of our favorite things about CarShield is its variety of coverage options. With six auto warranty plans to choose from, we can easily find a plan that suits our individual requirements.

Moreover, CarShield covers both new and high-mileage vehicles, providing a comprehensive solution for different car owners. So if you are wondering, what does CarShield cover? - the truth is, just about everything.

Transparent Pricing

Another aspect we appreciate about CarShield is its transparent pricing. On average, CarShield warranties cost between $109.99 and $139.99 per month, though the monthly payment may vary based on our chosen plan.

This price range makes it easy for us to know what we can expect when opting for CarShield's services. The CarShield cost is reasonable considering how much it can save you in the long run too.

Highly-rated Customer Service

Last but not least, we are impressed by CarShield's highly-rated customer service. CarShield demonstrates its commitment to providing excellent support and assistance to its customers.

This gives us a sense of trust and peace of mind when selecting CarShield as our extended warranty provider. The CarShield reviews would also back up this claim, as they have tons of positive reviews online and rank as one of the best-extended car warranty companies.

What is Not Covered by CarShield?

It’s not all perfect, though. Your CarShield contract will also explain what they don’t cover. So it’s a good idea to get familiar with this section so you avoid signing up for Car Shield only to find out they don’t cover your issue.

Routine Maintenance

Routine maintenance, including oil changes, tire rotations, brake pad replacements, and tune-ups, is typically not covered by CarShield.

These tasks are part of the ongoing responsibilities of owning a vehicle and are not included in CarShield's service contracts. Always adhere to your vehicle's maintenance schedule to keep your car in top shape and prevent costly repairs down the line.

Pre-Existing Conditions

CarShield, like most service contract providers, does not cover pre-existing conditions. This means if your vehicle has mechanical issues that were present before the service contract began, the costs to repair these problems won't be covered.

This is why it's crucial to keep your vehicle in good condition and address mechanical issues promptly. This is the company’s way to avoid being scammed by customers. But don’t worry, there are plenty of covered repairs.

Cosmetic Items

Cosmetic issues, such as damages to the paint, upholstery, or bodywork, are generally not covered by CarShield's service contracts. These are considered non-mechanical in nature and thus fall outside the scope of most vehicle service contracts.

Therefore, maintaining your vehicle's appearance is a crucial part of car ownership that falls upon the owner's shoulders. So if you expect payment for this, you’ll need to look for other extended warranties.

Wear and Tear

Items subject to normal wear and tear, such as belts, hoses, or wipers, are typically not included in CarShield's coverage. Over time, these items naturally degrade and need replacing as part of routine vehicle maintenance.

Hence, it's vital to inspect these components and replace them when necessary regularly. You really won’t find many options that do handle these repairs.

Damage from Accidents or Misuse

Damage resulting from accidents, misuse of the vehicle, or improper maintenance is usually not covered by CarShield. This exclusion emphasizes the importance of safe driving and properly caring for your vehicle.

If damage is due to collision or negligence, repair costs will likely be out of pocket. You can try to file CarShield claims for these problems, but it’s rare to see CarShield pay for this. Always check your CarShield coverage too.

Non-Mechanical Components

Non-mechanical components, such as the vehicle's glass or lights, are often excluded from CarShield's coverage. Although these parts are vital to the vehicle, they're not considered mechanical components, and their repair or replacement isn't typically covered under service contracts.

How Much Does CarShield Cost?

The average cost of a CarShield vehicle protection plan is between $99.99 and $129.99 per month. However, their highest level of coverage typically falls between $100 and $140 per month, with the total cost ranging from $2,000 to $3,000.

You can also speak to a CarShield customer service representative about custom pricing plans. They also work directly with American Auto Shield to handle claims faster, which is why the price is so attractive.

CarShield offers different coverage plans to cater to various customer needs, such as powertrain, comprehensive, and specialty plans for unique vehicles. Some customers might find it more convenient to opt for a monthly payment plan, while others might prefer to pay for their coverage upfront, depending on their budget and preferences.

As a friendly reminder, it is essential to assess your personal needs and budget before jumping into any protection plan. Every vehicle and situation is unique, making it crucial to consider each coverage option carefully and compare the costs associated with them.

Is CarShield Worth It?

In reviewing the myriad of CarShield warranty reviews available online, a common question among potential customers is whether CarShield is worth the investment. From my perspective as an auto expert, the answer is a resounding yes, and here's why.

CarShield's customizable plans offer a significant advantage. Their variety of plans allows you to tailor the coverage to your specific needs, ensuring you only pay for what you require. Whether you drive a high-mileage vehicle or a relatively new one, there's likely a plan that will provide the coverage you need.

CarShield's approval from the Better Business Bureau further bolsters its worth. With this positive standing, you can have confidence that CarShield is a reliable company committed to customer satisfaction.

Plus, there are numerous CarShield plans to choose from, and it’s easy to cancel CarShield if you are unhappy with the offering. Overall, the CarShield extended warranty is the best option we’ve found thus far.

CarShield Vs. Competitors

While CarShield offers an excellent range of extended auto warranty plans, there are several other noteworthy providers in the market. Carchex, Autopom!, and Endurance are among these competitors, each with their unique approach to extended auto warranty services.


Carchex is a leading provider of extended auto warranties known for its customer-oriented approach. They offer five levels of coverage, including Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum, and Titanium.

Carchex caters to a diverse range of vehicles, especially older, high-mileage cars. They also provide a 30-day money-back guarantee, ensuring complete customer satisfaction.


Autopom! operates with a philosophy of high transparency and customer consultation. They offer four types of plans: Powertrain Plus, Mid Level, High Level, and Exclusionary.

This approach helps customers to find the right coverage plan for their specific needs, thus creating a tailored service experience. They also offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, showing their commitment to customer satisfaction.


Endurance is unique due to its direct-to-consumer model, allowing the company to provide comprehensive and competitively priced extended warranty plans. They offer four different plans - Secure, Select Premier, Superior, and Supreme.

The plans are designed to suit a variety of vehicle types and customer needs. Plus, Endurance provides additional benefits like roadside assistance and trip interruption coverage, enhancing the value proposition.

CarShield Review: Unbiased Evaluation

About The Author

Charles Redding

Charles Redding

I've spent many years selling cars, working with auto detailers, mechanics, dealership service teams, quoting and researching car insurance, modding my own cars, and much more.

Read More About Charles Redding