Owning a Subaru Legacy should be an exciting time for drivers, so don’t let choosing the best tire be a stressful endeavor. Instead of stressing, let us help!  

Always do a little bit of research prior to purchasing tires to make sure you are getting the perfect fit for your vehicle and the area where you live. Knowing the weather you will mostly be driving in is crucial when looking for tires for your Subaru Legacy.

Tires perform best when they are driven in the intended situations and areas. For instance, a winter tire will not perform as well if you are driving in hot, summer temperatures on a long road trip. If you are ever confused about what your tire needs are, always talk to a professional.

Here is a list that is intended to help narrow down your search by giving you the top two tires in each of the five most popular categories. We are sure this list will be beneficial to finding the best tires for your Subaru Legacy.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

HideShow

10 Best Tires for Subaru Legacy

As the mid-sized car offered by Subaru, the Legacy has been driving the streets of the world since 1989. This vehicle has been a top choice of car buyers for a number of reasons, one of which being the option to have four wheel drive in a sedan.

Once the vehicle is purchased, however, many people have struggled with knowing which of the thousands of tires on the market is the right fit for the Subaru Legacy. Finding the right tires can be stressful, but is so important to make sure you get the most out of your vehicle purchase by making the right choice for tires.

Below is a list of the 10 most popular tire choices for the Subaru Legacy. These tires have all be tried, tested and reviewed by customers, and are all recommended as excellent tire choices.

Since we have done all of the research necessary, we hope this is an easy process for you. All that’s left to do is choose a category and make a selection to get the perfect set of tires on your car to enjoy your time on the streets.

Type of Tire Tire
All-Season General Altimax RT43
Continental TrueContact
Touring Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus
Michelin Premier A/S
High Performance Michelin Pilot Sport A/S3 Plus
Continental ExtremeContact DWS
Summer Firestone Firehawk Indy 500
Bridgestone Potenza S-04 Pole Position
Winter Continental ExtremeWinterContact
Bridgestone Blizzak LM-32

General Altimax RT43 - Best All-Season Tire

The General Altimax RT43 tire has long been a top choice for car owners because of comfort and reliability. With “RT” in the name, this tire is known for its “road touring” capabilities, making it possible for you to travel over a number of different road surfaces without skipping a beat.

The driver and passenger’s comfort level is a high priority of this tire manufacturer, and they worked to design a tire that allowed you to drive over various road conditions without feeling bumps or vibrations inside the vehicle. This is accomplished by the Low Surface Abrasion Technology that is built into the tread pattern of the tire.

The General Altimax RT43 tire is also made with Peak Anti-Slip Design Technology which allows the tire to stay in contact with the road at all times and through any weather situation. Regardless of the season outside, you can trust your tires to be reliable and safely get you to your destination!

There are two helpful features to this tire - the Replacement Tire Monitors which allow the driver to see exactly when the tires need to be looked at or even replaced, as well as the Visual Alignment Indicators which will tell you how the alignment is on your vehicle.

Where To Buy General Altimax RT43

Discount Tire Tire Buyer Tire Rack

Specifications

  • Warranty: 65,000 miles
  • Max Inflation Pressure: 51 PSI
  • Tread Depth: 10”
  • Tire Weight: 26 lbs
  • Load Index: 100
  • UTQG Treadwear: 700
  • UTQG Traction: A
  • UTQG Temperature: A

FAQ

What sizes are available for the General Altimax RT43 tire?

This tire comes in a wide range of sizes from 13”-20”, making it possible for you to find the perfect fit for your Subaru Legacy.

What is the load capacity?

The load capacity is 1,356 pounds for this tire.

Are these tires directional?

No, they are not! This means that you are free to rotate your tires as you wish around the vehicle, as the traction will not be affected.

Continental TrueContact - Best All-Season Tire

Oftentimes all-season and touring tires offer similar features, and the Continental TrueContact tire is one that falls in both of these categories. With these tires on your Subaru Legacy, you cannot go wrong! This is a reliable tire manufacturer with amazing features to keep you safe at all times.

Through any weather situation, your Continental TrueContact tires will stay gripped to the road, making you as safe as possible while traveling. Built with Continental EcoPlus Technology, your tire will experience a longer tread life and have great traction when the roads get slippery.

Being able to navigate weather conditions can be tricky, but with an all-season tire you are sure to always be protected and safe, rain or shine. These tires have also been reviewed for snowy weather and perform well.

With little to no road noise from within the vehicle, Continental TrueContact tires are a hot tire choice for Subaru Legacy drivers. These tires are also backed by a 70,000 - 80,000 mile warranty!

Where To Buy Continental TrueContact

Tire Rack

Specifications

  • Warranty: 70,000 - 80,000 miles
  • Max Inflation Pressure: 44 - 51 PSI
  • Tread Depth: 11”
  • Tire Weight: 15 - 30 lbs
  • Load Index: 84 - 104
  • UTQG Treadwear: 700-800
  • UTQG Traction: A
  • UTQG Temperature: A - B

FAQ

What is the load capacity of the Continental TrueContact tire?

The load capacity is 1,874 pounds.

What sizes are available?

The Continental TrueContact tire is available in sizes 15”-19”.

How is the road noise with this tire?

On a scale of 1-10, this tire was given a rating of 8.8 for road noise and 9.2 for overall ride quality. With a set of Continental TrueContact tires on your Subaru Legacy, you are sure to have a peaceful and enjoyable drive!

Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus - Best Touring Tire

Touring tires are designed to take drivers the distance! Whether you are embarking on a long road trip, or if you have a long commute to and from work then this is the right choice for you. People who spend a long time on the road need a dependable tire that is designed to make your drive more enjoyable.

Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus tires are a luxury line of tires for the touring category. This tire is designed to make your ride comfortable by creating little to no road noise from inside the vehicle. The tire was designed with a wide shoulder tread that keeps your vehicle driving straight, regardless of the road conditions in the area you are driving. Maintaining control over road changes is crucial to staying safe while driving around!

Pirelli created this tire with a pitch sequencing tread pattern which allows for the car to travel without creating noise. With the ability to navigate wet road conditions, your Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus tires are helpful in rain, light snow, or sunshine.

Another thing customers don’t often consider when looking at tires is the fuel efficiency features offered. Pirelli took this into consideration when creating this tire and made it incredibly fuel efficient for drivers, making it an excellent tire choice.

Where To Buy Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus

Discount Tire Tire Buyer Tire Rack

Specifications

  • Warranty: 70,000 miles
  • Max Inflation Pressure: 44-51 PSI
  • Tread Depth: 10”
  • Tire Weight: 17-33 lbs
  • Load Index: 87-102
  • UTQG Treadwear: 700
  • UTQG Traction: A
  • UTQG Temperature: A

FAQ

What sizes are available?

The Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season Plus tire comes in sizes 16”-20”.

What is the load capacity?

The load capacity is 1,389 on this tire.

How do these tires drive in winter weather conditions?

This touring tire is designed to handle a variety of road and weather conditions, but if you plan to drive on ice or snow frequently, it might not be the best choice. It can handle light snow and ice, but not severe weather situations.

Michelin Premier A/S - Best Touring Tire

When traveling to and from your destination, you want to make sure you have a reliable and trustworthy tire on your vehicle. Choosing Michelin Premier A/S tires is always a safe choice for Subaru Legacy drivers.

This is a tire created to handle all seasons of weather conditions, hence the “A/S” in the name. If you are trying to maintain traction with the road while it is raining, then this tire will be there to help you stop safely. With Evergrip Technology, your tire will be able to brake and handle turns easily due to its ability to always grip the ground beneath.

Michelin Premier A/S tires have a long tread life and wear evenly as the tires age. Depending on your plans for how far you will travel, always trust Michelin Premier A/S tires to handle any amount of miles you are wanting to go!

Backed by a 60,000 mile warranty, these tires will not let you down. If you are looking for a great touring tire for your vehicle, then look no further than Michelin Premier A/S tires.

Where To Buy Michelin Premier A/S

Discount Tire Tire Buyer Tire Rack

Specifications

  • Warranty: 60,000 miles
  • Max Inflation Pressure: 44 PSI
  • Tread Depth: 9”
  • Tire Weight: 21 lbs
  • Load Index: 87
  • UTQG Treadwear: 640
  • UTQG Traction: A
  • UTQG Temperature: A

FAQ

What sizes are available in the Michelin Premier A/S tire?

This tire is available in sizes 15”-19”.

What is the load capacity?

Depending on the size of tire purchased, these tires can carry anywhere from 1,074 - 1,477 pounds.

How is the road noise?

On a scale of 1-10, this tire was rated 8.5 for road noise and an 8.9 for ride quality.

Michelin Pilot Sport A/S3 Plus - Best High Performance Tire

High performance tires were created to give drivers the ability to maximize handling of the vehicle, turn corners easily, as well as accelerate and brake with ease. Typically speaking, people who drive with performance tires on their car enjoy driving at faster speeds.

The Michelin Pilot Sport A/S3 Plus tire was created to handle all of the high performance tire needs all while having all season capabilities, hence the “A/S” in the name. This tire is created to perform, and we think you will find this to be a trustworthy tire choice for your Subaru Legacy.

This tire can handle wet or dry road conditions, even though it was created for driving on dry roads at high speeds, making it a great option for any season of the year. Built with 3D sipes, the water is pushed away from the tire which prevents hydroplaning in rainy conditions.

When driving fast and braking in short distances, the “biting edges” in the tread will make this possible and safe at the same time! Choosing a high performance, all-season tire will allow you to cruise while being comfortable and safe.

Where To Buy Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3 Plus

Discount Tire Tire Buyer Tire Rack

Specifications

  • Warranty: 45,000 miles
  • Max Inflation Pressure: 50 PSI
  • Tread Depth: 11”
  • Tire Weight: 25 lbs
  • Load Index: 94
  • UTQG Treadwear: 500
  • UTQG Traction: AA
  • UTQG Temperature: A

FAQ

What is the load capacity?

The load capacity of the Michelin Pilot Sport A/S3 tire is 1,356 pounds.

What sizes are available?

This tire comes in sizes 16”-22”, making it possible for you to find the perfect size for your Subaru Legacy.

How is the road noise?

While most high performance tires are said to have a lot of road noise, this tire was rated an 8.2 for road noise and an 8.7 for overall ride quality, on a scale of 1-10.

Continental ExtremeContact DWS - Best High Performance Tire

Do you have a need for speed? Do you like taking corners quicker than the average driver? If so, then you are the perfect customer for high performance tire manufacturers. High performance tires allow you to drive as you wish, all while staying as safe as possible.

When you are out driving, having the ability to brake as necessary is crucial to the safety of you and other drivers on the road. The Continental ExtremeContact DWS tire was created to be able to maintain traction in any weather condition, any time of the year. The “DWS'' in the name of this tire refers to its ability to drive in dry, wet or snowy conditions.

For added responsiveness when handling this vehicle, the manufacturer included a Sport Sidewall Insert to increase your capabilities while driving with these tires. Continental ExtremeContact DWS tires have a long tread life, and make for a very comfortable driving experience for passengers inside the vehicle.

Backed by a 50,000 mile warranty, these tires will take you the distance, while allowing you to have a little fun in the process. Always be safe when driving, but you can relax knowing your vehicle is equipped with Continental ExtremeContact DWS tires.

Where To Buy Continental Extreme Contact DWS 06

Discount Tire Tire Buyer Tire Rack

Specifications

  • Warranty: 50,000 miles
  • Max Inflation Pressure: 51 PSI
  • Tread Depth: 10”
  • Tire Weight: 22 lbs
  • Load Index:
  • UTQG Treadwear: 560
  • UTQG Traction: AA
  • UTQG Temperature: A

FAQ

What sizes are available?

This tire comes in sizes 16”-22”.

What is the load capacity?

The Continental ExtremeContact DWS tire can carry up to 1,356 pounds.

How do these tires drive on snow?

While not intended for intense winter weather conditions, this tire performs pretty well in light snow or ice.

Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 - Best Summer Tire

Owning Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 tires means that you are more than likely a person who enjoys going for long car drives in the summertime! This summer time is built to withstand the mileage and various weather conditions that might be thrown your way.

A tire’s ability to navigate wet or dry roads easily is something a lot of people look for. Maintaining traction through water on the road can be tricky, but the Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 tire handles it without even thinking twice.

For maximum safety, it is important to note that this tire was not designed to handle heavy winter weather conditions. You will have minimal to no traction on ice, so be sure to take this into consideration before purchasing or driving, as safety is the most important thing to consider when dealing with vehicles.

For handling high speeds and increasing stability and handling, the manufacturer created this tire with a unique internal design, including a high-turn-up polyester casing, nylon reinforcement, as well as steel belts. From concept to cruising, this tire was well thought out and created to help you enjoy your vehicle as much as possible.

Where To Buy Firestone Firehawk Indy 500

Tire Rack

Specifications

  • Warranty: N/A
  • Max Inflation Pressure: 50-51 PSI
  • Tread Depth: 9-10”
  • Tire Weight: 19-25 lbs
  • Load Index: 94
  • UTQG Treadwear: 340
  • UTQG Traction: A
  • UTQG Temperature: A

FAQ

What is the load capacity?

The load capacity for Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 tires is 1,477 pounds.

What sizes are available?

These tires come anywhere from 16”-20”.

How is the road noise?

These tires create little to no road noise, making it possible for you to enjoy your drive and listen to your music, not the road beneath!

Bridgestone Potenza S-04 Pole Position- Best Summer Tire

Finding a good summer tire can be a challenge, but the top thing customers look for is the ability to handle speed. Most people enjoy taking their vehicle with summer tires out for long road trips or cruises on sunny days, so having control of the vehicle and making sure you can brake in the necessary amount of time are crucial components.

If you are in this category, then look no further than the Bridgestone Potenza S-04 Pole Position tire. This summer tire offers reliable traction that is able to stay in contact with the road in wet or dry conditions. When it comes to summertime, oftentimes the weather can be unpredictable and the last thing you want to be worrying about are the tires on your Subaru Legacy.

Hydroplaning is essentially eliminated with the grooves in the tread of the tire and you will feel like you are driving a race car with these tires on your vehicle. There are parts of this tire that are designed to help increase the steering abilities as well as braking response time. These two things can often be affected by water on the road, but with a set of Bridgestone Potenza S-04 Pole Position tires on your car, you are unstoppable!

To up your Subaru Legacy driving game, be sure to check out Bridgestone Potenza S-04 Pole Position tires!

Where To Buy Bridgestone Potenza S-04 Pole Position

Discount Tire Tire Rack

Specifications

  • Warranty: N/A
  • Max Inflation Pressure: 50-51 PSI
  • Tread Depth: 10”
  • Tire Weight: 23-34 lbs
  • Load Index: 88-102
  • UTQG Treadwear: 280
  • UTQG Traction: AA
  • UTQG Temperature: A

FAQ

What sizes are available?

These tires are available in sizes 16”-20”.

What is the load capacity?

The load capacity is 1,565 pounds for the Bridgestone Potenza S-04 Pole Position tire.

How do these tires drive in winter weather conditions?

These tires are designed for summertime driving and are not recommended for winter weather conditions at all.

Continental ExtremeWinterContact - Best Winter Tire

Maintaining contact with the road is important for drivers trying to navigate snowy or icy conditions on a regular basis. If you live in a place where you experience frequent winter weather conditions, then having a set of winter tires might be the best option for you.

Continental ExtremeWinterContact provides exactly what the name states - extreme winter contact! With an asymmetric tread pattern, your winter tires will grip the ground even when there is a layer of ice or snow on the ground.

When a tire is in extreme cold temperatures, it needs to be able to expand and contract as necessary. Built with a rubber compound that is able to stay flexible, the Continental ExtremeWinterContact tire is an excellent choice.

Most winter tires have a directional tread which means that when rotating your tires, you are only able to move them forwards and backwards to make sure the tread always rolls in the same direction. Always double check before getting your tires rotated to make sure your vehicle has as much contact with the ground as possible!

Specifications

  • Warranty: 50,000 miles
  • Max Inflation Pressure: 50 PSI
  • Tread Depth: 11”
  • Tire Weight: 24 lbs
  • Load Index: 102
  • UTQG Treadwear: N/A
  • UTQG Traction: N/A
  • UTQG Temperature: N/A

FAQ

What are the available sizes?

This tire is available in 57 different sizes! This means that you can find the perfect fit for your vehicle without having to worry about size.

What is the load capacity?

Depending on the size purchased, these tires have a load capacity of 1,047 pounds to 3,417 pounds.

Do these tires perform well with summer driving?

The Continental ExtremeWinterContact tire was designed for very cold temperatures and driving on ice or snow, so they are not ideal for summertime driving if you live in an area with a warmer climate.

Bridgestone Blizzak LM-32 - Best Winter Tire

Winter driving can be very dangerous and not ideal for drivers without experience, or for cars without the proper tires installed. If you know you are going to be driving in extreme winter weather conditions, then making sure your Subaru Legacy is equipped with winter tires is a great way to stay as safe as possible.

Look no further than the Bridgestone Blizzak LM-32 tire to continue driving as you normally would in these less than ideal conditions. With a directional tread, you will stay in contact with the road even through snow or ice.

There are sipes built into the tread that have one job - to help cut through the ice beneath the vehicle. With a 3-Peak Mountain Snowflake Rating, you can be sure that this tire has been tested and tried in extreme weather and proven to be a great option.

Winter tires are able to handle the lower temperatures with ease, allowing you to relax as you navigate these less than ideal conditions. When the winter weather comes, you do not have to stay in to avoid the roads. Instead, you can take them on confidently, knowing that your Subaru Legacy can handle the elements.

Where To Buy Bridgestone Blizzak LM-32

Discount Tire Tire Rack

Specifications

  • Warranty: N/A
  • Max Inflation Pressure: 36-51 PSI
  • Tread Depth: 9”-12”
  • Tire Weight: 23-36 lbs
  • Load Index: 93-105
  • UTQG Treadwear: N/A
  • UTQG Traction: N/A
  • UTQG Temperature: N/A

FAQ

What sizes are available?

These tires are available in sizes 17”-20”.

What is the load capacity?

The load capacity is 1,079 pounds.

Can these tires drive in warmer temperatures?

These tires are designed to maintain traction with the road, so while they are an excellent choice for winter road conditions, it is not recommended that you drive them in warmer weather.

Buyer’s Guide

What To Look For in Your New Tires

Knowing what to look for in your tires will help you to narrow down your search and make the right choice. Here are a few things to consider when you begin your new tire hunt.

  • Brand - There are a number of brands available for tire purchase, but it never hurts to ask an expert for their opinion for your particular vehicle. If you are loyal to a particular brand, then sticking with that brand is recommended for you.
  • Tread - The tread depth varies from tire to tire, but the thing to look for is whether or not the tread is directional. When dealing with winter tires, most are directional and can only be rotated forwards and backwards to make sure they always travel in the same direction that they were originally installed on.
  • Type - All-Season, Touring, Summer and Winter are a few of the most popular tire categories on the market. Most people are able to locate their ideal tire from these categories, but if you need help narrowing it down, the tire store salesmen should be able to assist you in any way you need.
  • Size - Most tires come in a variety of sizes, making it where you can find the perfect fit for your particular vehicle. If you are unsure of the size you need, always check with the professionals or look on the tire to find the sizing listed.
  • Road Noise - Some tires create more noise than others when driving down the road. This can greatly affect the comfort of the driver and passengers while traveling, so for maximum comfort, always find a tire that has little to no road noise.
  • Tread Wear - The tread on tires does not always wear at the same rate, so oftentimes they are rotated in order to get the most out of the tire purchase and to help keep the alignment of the vehicle where it needs to be.
  • Speed - If you enjoy long and fast drives, then you are going to want to find a tire that can keep up with the necessary demand. Oftentimes, people who drive quicker than the average driver enjoy getting a set of high performance tires on their vehicle.
  • Distance - The intended mileage travelled is something else that needs to be taken into consideration because not every tire is designed to handle long distances. Touring tires are the perfect choice for people looking to take a long road trip or for those who spend a lot of time behind the wheel on the roads.
  • Weather - Does it snow a lot where you live? Or are you used to driving on wet roads because of the constant threat of thunderstorms? Regardless of your answer, the fact of the matter is that your area and the weather conditions there must be taken into consideration when dealing with making a tire choice. Traction with the road is the most important component and knowing what your needs are prior to looking for a tire will help narrow down the hunt and make it less overwhelming for you.

About THE AUTHOR

Charles Redding

Charles Redding

I've spent many years selling cars, working with auto detailers, mechanics, dealership service teams, quoting and researching car insurance, modding my own cars, and much more.

Read More About Charles Redding