Key Takeaways

  • Endurance stands out for excellent customer service and comprehensive coverage options.
  • CarShield offers affordability and specialized plans for high-mileage vehicles.
  • Both companies are accredited by the BBB, emphasizing their commitment to quality service.

This post may include affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we'll receive a commission at no extra cost to you. This support helps us maintain and grow our site. Thank you for your support!

When it comes to choosing an extended warranty for your vehicle, two popular options are Endurance and CarShield. So how do they compare?

Endurance and CarShield are leading car warranty providers. While Endurance is praised for excellent customer service and comprehensive plans, CarShield stands out for its affordability, especially for high-mileage vehicles. Both offer varied customer coverage options.

Both companies offer comprehensive coverage options, such as bumper-to-bumper coverage and basic powertrain coverage, as well as additional benefits like roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, and trip interruption coverage. In this guide, we will compare and contrast these two extended warranty providers to help you make an informed decision about which one is the best fit for your needs.

Table of Contents

Endurance Vs. CarShield: Unpacking Vehicle Protection Plans

When comparing Endurance vs. CarShield, the differences mainly lie in cost and customer service. Endurance is known to have better customer service, while CarShield is often praised for its affordability.

Both companies cater to car owners looking for extended warranty coverage for their high-mileage vehicles. Before we dive right in, let’s compare CarShield and Endurance to see how they match up.

Comparison Criteria CarShield Endurance
Trust Factor 3.9 4.4
Policy Flexibility 4.7 4.8
Cost Efficiency 4.8 4.4
User Experience 4.6 4.9
Claim Processing 3.8 4.2
Overall Rating 4.3 4.5

Both CarShield and Endurance have positive customer reviews. They are both accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB), and their extended warranties stand out in the market.

No matter which company you choose for your extended car warranty needs, it's crucial to carefully review their coverage plans, coverage limits, and monthly payments to make the best choice.

Endurance: An Overview

Endurance Vehicle Protection Plans
Endurance Vehicle Protection Plans

We can't talk about extended warranty coverage without mentioning Endurance, one of the most popular providers in the industry. Offering a range of options for car owners seeking comprehensive coverage, Endurance is a direct provider of vehicle service contracts.

Endurance's extended warranties cater to both new and high-mileage vehicles, with coverage designed to meet various customer needs. They offer several coverage plans, ranging from basic powertrain coverage to more comprehensive, bumper-to-bumper coverage options.

These plans even cater to specialty coverage for certain components like electrical components, air conditioning, and cooling systems. Car owners can expect a host of benefits from Endurance warranties, especially with their Endurance Elite Benefits program).

This program includes perks such as roadside assistance, trip interruption coverage, and rental car reimbursement, among other useful benefits. What's more, their coverage offers flexibility on repairs, as you can choose the repair shop that meets both your needs and preferences.

CarShield: An Overview

CarShield Vehicle Protection Plans
CarShield Vehicle Protection Plans

Founded in 2005, CarShield is a popular extended car warranty provider known for its affordable pricing and various coverage options. One of the things that stands out about CarShield is its extensive range of coverage plans.

Catering to different needs and budgets, these plans feature everything from basic powertrain coverage to comprehensive bumper-to-bumper warranties. As avid drivers ourselves, we particularly appreciate CarShield's dedication to high-mileage vehicles.

We've found that they offer vehicle service contracts that address the unique needs of cars with significant mileage under their belt. This is a fantastic relief for car owners who might not find such support elsewhere.

CarShield also ensures that car owners have access to additional perks like rental car reimbursement, roadside assistance, and trip interruption coverage. This demonstrates their commitment to making vehicle ownership as hassle-free as possible.

CarShield vs. Endurance: Coverage Plans

When comparing CarShield and Endurance, it's important to consider their coverage plans. Both companies provide a range of options to cater to different needs. In this section, we'll examine the extended warranty plans offered by CarShield and Endurance.

CarShield Extended Warranty Plans

CarShield offers a variety of coverage options to suit the needs of different car owners. Some of the key plans available include:

  • Diamond: This plan is similar to a manufacturer's warranty and provides comprehensive, bumper-to-bumper coverage for all major systems in your vehicle.
  • Platinum: Designed for high-mileage vehicles, this comprehensive coverage protects both your engine and transmission and your vehicle's electrical and cooling systems.
  • Gold: A good choice for older vehicles, this coverage focuses on powertrain components and includes protection for your vehicle's engine, transmission, and drive axle.

CarShield also provides coverage options like specialty plans for all-terrain vehicles, motorcycles, and RVs. In addition, you can expect to find features like roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, and trip interruption coverage available across most of their plans.

Endurance Extended Warranty Plans

Endurance, a direct provider of extended warranties, offers coverage plans tailored to your specific needs. They include:

  • Supreme: Mirroring a bumper-to-bumper factory warranty, this plan offers the highest level of coverage for mechanical and electrical components.
  • Superior: A component coverage plan that covers hundreds of essential components of your vehicle, including air conditioning, fuel delivery, and suspension systems.
  • Secure Plus: Designed for older high-mileage vehicles, this plan focuses on powertrain coverage and essential components such as the engine, transmission, and drive axle.

Just like CarShield, Endurance also offers additional benefits like roadside assistance, rental car coverage, and trip interruption coverage. Their plans are also backed by their Endurance Elite Benefits Program, which includes perks like key fob replacements, repair financing, and tire repair or replacements.

Comparison: Endurance Vs. CarShield

If you need a vehicle service contract, both of these brands are worth considering. But exactly how do they compare?

Coverage Options

When comparing Endurance vs CarShield, it's evident that both companies offer a variety of coverage options to suit different needs. Endurance provides comprehensive coverage, including bumper-to-bumper coverage and basic powertrain coverage.

CarShield, on the other hand, offers specialty coverage for high-mileage vehicles and even covers all-terrain vehicles. Additionally, both CarShield and Endurance offer a range of extended warranty plans from stated component coverage to more extensive options.

Roadside assistance, trip interruption coverage, rental car reimbursement, and coverage for electrical components are common features in these extended warranties for both companies.


In terms of cost, the prices vary depending on the chosen plan, vehicle, and mileage. Car owners can expect to pay different rates with each warranty provider. Generally speaking, CarShield tends to have more affordable pricing, particularly in the short term.

This is due in part to their extensive range of coverage plans catering to various budgets. On the other hand, Endurance may offer lower rates for long-term contracts. Monthly payments are a common option for both CarShield and Endurance.

This makes their extended warranty plans more accessible for many car owners. However, it's important to get personalized quotes from both companies to compare their pricing more accurately.

Bumper-To-Bumper Warranty Costs

Term Length Down Payment Total Cost Cost Per Year of Coverage
CarShield Unlimited $139.99/monthly First month's payment $1,679.88
Endurance 5 years/100,000 miles $114.00 for 30 months $300.00 $3,420.00

Powertrain Warranty Costs

Term Length Down Payment Total Cost Cost Per Year of Coverage
CarShield Unlimited month-to-month plan $109.99/month One month's payment $1,319.88
Endurance 5 years/54,000 miles $133.28/month for 24 months $153.00 $3,198.72


When evaluating the reputation of CarShield and Endurance, customer reviews can provide valuable insights. Both companies have mixed reviews, with some customers praising their extended warranty coverage and others expressing dissatisfaction.

CarShield has been accredited by the Better Business Bureau and holds an A+ rating, while Endurance is also accredited with a B+ rating. This indicates that both companies strive to provide quality service and uphold good business practices.

Endurance appears to have better customer satisfaction when it comes to providing automotive service excellence, whereas CarShield has a reputation for being more affordable.

Winner - Endurance has a better reputation and is more trusted in the industry.

Which Is Cheaper: CarShield Or Endurance?

CarShield is known for its short-term contracts that are generally cheaper than Endurance's long-term counterparts. This choice can be attractive for those looking for coverage on used or high-mileage vehicles without a lengthy commitment.

CarShield coverage plans also cater to specialty vehicles like all-terrain vehicles (ATVs) and motorcycles, which can be unique to this provider. On the other hand, Endurance sometimes offers lower rates for long-term contracts, which can be a great fit for those who plan to keep their vehicles for an extended period.

With various coverage options, including basic powertrain coverage and comprehensive bumper-to-bumper coverage, Endurance aims to provide the best possible coverage for the consumer's needs.

Winner - CarShield is cheaper because you pay month to month with lower premiums.

Which Is Better CarShield Or Endurance?

CarShield is known for offering affordable pricing and a variety of coverage plans, making it a great option for car owners in need of protection for their high-mileage vehicles. They also provide extended warranty coverage to cover repair costs and offer plans with specialized coverage, such as those for all-terrain vehicles.

On the other hand, Endurance is praised for its excellent customer service and comprehensive coverage plans. As a direct provider of extended warranties, Endurance is known for making the claims process easier and faster for its customers.

In addition, Endurance offers perks like roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, and trip interruption coverage as part of their Endurance Elite Benefits program. One of the factors to consider in the CarShield vs. Endurance debate is the range of coverage options each company offers.

CarShield has plans that cover basic powertrain components, factory warranty, specialty coverage, and even stated component coverage. This makes it a great choice for car owners looking for flexibility in their extended warranty.

Winner - Endurance coverage is better, but it comes at a premium cost.

Endurance Vs CarShield: Unpacking Vehicle Protection Plans

About The Author

Charles Redding

Charles Redding

I've spent many years selling cars, working with auto detailers, mechanics, dealership service teams, quoting and researching car insurance, modding my own cars, and much more.

Read More About Charles Redding