This post may include affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we'll receive a commission at no extra cost to you. This support helps us maintain and grow our site. Thank you for your support!

Tires can wear over time which might hurt performance. You'll need a replacement at some point, and the decision may come down to Discount Tire vs Costco.

There are so many alternatives that deciding what to buy can be tough. Discount Tire and Costco are two sites where you may save a lot of money buying car tires. However, you will have to deep dive into Discount Tire vs. Costco to understand each company’s offering and find out which is the better option for your car.

Discount Tire carries a wider range of tire brands and models. They also offer a low-price guarantee, ensuring that you obtain the greatest deal available. Out-of-stock tires are common at Costco, although they come with a somewhat stronger warranty than Discount Tires.

It can be difficult to choose between them since they are pretty even in most areas. However, you're not alone if you're split between these two main tire retailers. This comparison is debated in many forums. However, we want to put an end to the discussion here. Continue reading to learn more about Discount Tire vs. Costco, as well as some helpful hints for selecting the best tire for your needs.

When it comes to purchasing a new pair of tires, the information we provide will assist you in making a more informed decision. Take the time to read through the benefits and drawbacks of each site compared here before making your decision. The information provided below is based on personal experience and research on authoritative sites spanning over 15 hours.

Table of Contents

Discount Tire vs Costco: A Comprehensive Comparison of the Two

While it can be hard to choose from the many options you have, this Discount Tire vs Costco comparison will assist you in making your decision. Both Discount Tire and Costco provide a large assortment of products from some of the most well-known global companies, all of which are available at reasonable costs.

If you didn't know, Discount Tires is also known as America's Tires in other parts of the country. The company claims a base price of $21,which includes several different services. On the other hand, Costco advertises a $60 annual membership on its website.

Costco members have the option of purchasing tires online or at a warehouse club location. If you buy them online, Costco will deliver them for free to a nearby store.

Continue reading to see how each store compares to the other so you can choose the best one for your needs.

1. Pricing

Many people will undoubtedly base their decision on the tire price. You're undoubtedly looking for the best prices available, especially if you're on a budget. The good news is that both suppliers provide high-quality tires at a reasonable price. But, which one has a more affordable selection?

Discount tires have more affordable costs. These tires are cost-effective and suitable for folks on a tight budget.

Owners of cars are also permitted to avoid paying full price when replacing them in the future. Tires from Costco are a little on the pricey side.

The high price is because road dangers are included in the tire's pricing. However, due to their outstanding performance, these tires are well worth the investment.

Discount Tire, on average, is the less expensive of the two. According to Consumer Reports, the average tire cost at Discount Tire is typically lower than Costco.

Discount Tire will go to great lengths to ensure that you get the best deal on the tires you buy, owing to their Low Price Guarantee.

Discount Tire is significantly less expensive than Costco. Discount Tire also offers a low-match promise, which means that if you find the tires at a lower price someplace else, they will match it.

If you want to enjoy the benefits of Discount Tire's Low Price Guarantee, you must bring in a genuine ad with the advertised price.

Costco Tire is the winner in this area. Discount tires compel a person to pay an additional charge for certification of road hazards. The kind of road hazard warranty that is offered at a discount raises the price in the long term.

2. Selection of Tires

You must pick a reseller who has a wide range of tires so that you can compare your options. When considering the available possibilities, take into account the road conditions, size, and other factors.

Discount Tire has a larger assortment of tire brands than the other two. They offer tires from some of the world's best companies.

Discount Tire has a far larger selection of tires than Costco. Discount Tire will be your best bet if you enjoy the diversity and have a range of options to pick from.

As stated in the introduction, Discount Tire carries a wide range of brands. As a result, if you conduct an online search on their site, you will be able to find your preferred type. Furthermore, they can deliver it to you on the same day.

It's also worth mentioning that several of Costco's tires are regularly out of stock. With Discount Tire, that generally does not happen. They replenish their inventory regularly, guaranteeing that you can receive most tires when you need them.

For any automotive model, the discount tire has a larger assortment. The large capacity allows car aficionados to make more informed decisions before purchasing. All of the tires are suitable for car owners' likings.

Costco has many fewer tires in stock and far less volume. While Costco has a smaller range, the majority of the items are from well-known brands, so you can't go wrong with anything you pick.

The majority of tires on the market are designed for certain vehicles. Car owners often find it difficult to make a crucial decision before purchasing a tire.

Discount Tire is the winner in this area. The company works 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, to ensure that tires are in stock to meet the needs of their clients. The buyer can make a better judgment with a larger tire option.

3. Tire Warranty

It's critical to think about the retailer's guarantee for your peace of mind. The vendor will provide great support and service during the warranty period. Subject to the terms and conditions, this may encompass both repair and replacement.

In both Discount Tire and Costco's cases, you are covered by the tire manufacturer's warranty. However, the tire warranty at Costco is superior.

Costco is superior because it provides a five-year road hazard warranty. This is not the same as the manufacturer's warranty. Costco offers a free 5-year "Road Hazard Protection" coverage on all of its tires in addition to the normal tire manufacturer warranty.

Costco's guarantee covers tread degradation and damage for five years. If there is an issue with the tire during the warranty period, they will fix or replace it. If you choose a replacement, you will receive a credit on your purchase.

The same road hazard coverage is available from Discount Tire, but it is just for three years. Worse, unlike Costco, where the guarantee is included in the price of the tire, you will have to pay for it. Road hazard coverage is available from Discount Tire. For up to three years after purchase, the coverage provides your new tire set.

Many of the tires sold at Costco and Discount include a manufacturer's standard distance warranty. Depending on the manufacturer, these normally have a guarantee of 50k to 80k miles. If you travel 15k miles per year, you'll have enough coverage for 3-5 years.

Also, a three-year warranty is included when you acquire a Discount Tire Certificate. The additional cost will be determined by the tire brand you choose. It can cost anything from $10 to $100, which can be prohibitively expensive for some purchasers.

A Closer Look at the Warranty of Discount Tire

In addition to the manufacturer's usual distance guarantee, Discount Tire offers its own "Discount Tire Certificate," which functions as a three-year warranty.

You can get a complete refund or a replacement if your tires fail within this period. Keep in mind, however, that this warranty will cost you more per tire.

The cost of a product is determined by the brand and model. This charge might range from $10 to $100 per tire. Discount Tire does not offer a normal manufacturer's warranty on every tire it sells. The normal warranties on the tires do have varied lengths.

A Closer Look at the Tire Warranty of Costco

The Road Hazard Protection guarantee from Costco covers your tires for five years against tire breakdown or treadwear damage. If the tire fails or is damaged during that time range, Costco will replace or repair it. Costco is fair about this, and in most cases, their Road Hazard Warranty will be honored.

If you opt to have your tire replaced, Costco will give you credit on your purchase based on the amount of tread left on your tire.

4. Installation

Because Costco has a limit on the number of tires it will install for clients, Discount Tire will almost certainly provide better installation service.

Furthermore, Discount Tire occasionally provides packaged discounts that include installation and balance as part of the total purchase price. Discount Tire is a better value if you want a complete installation service.

Same-day tire installation is available at Discount Tire at a variety of hours. All of this information may be found on their schedule page. It also has the following features:

  • Installation booking for 10 days after the arrival of tires
  • Car drop-off

They also provide a helpful graph that shows you when the optimum time is to schedule an appointment. While you can install the tire on your own, most people choose to enlist the assistance of those who have the necessary tools and skills. Both stores provide installation services, so you can count on a helping hand from the pros.

While Discount Tire has a wider assortment of tires at lower prices, the average installation cost per tire is higher than Costco.

5. Customer Service

When comparing Costco tires to Discount Tire tires, it's not simply about who has more tires or who has the best deal. The importance of customer service to the overall experience cannot be overstated. This is also how loyalty is developed. It also specifies how to get the most bang for your cash.

Anyone who has purchased from Discount Tire or Costco knows that both companies provide excellent customer service. They have experts on staff who know what they're doing. You may expect a great encounter from the moment you meet their personnel, which will make you want to return.

What is the difference between Discount Tire and Costco, once again? Discount Tire and Costco are well-known tire retailers in the United States. Both have a great selection of high-quality products from well-known global companies at a reasonable price and both have great customer service.

But, if we had to choose one, we would pick Discount Tire. Discount tires have a higher level of commitment to their clients. When a consumer has a need, the brand has a team of personnel ready to assist them. In the event of repair services, there is no need to schedule an appointment or wait. Appointments and wait times at Costco Tires are insane.

Even in the case of urgent repairs, the company does not serve consumers without an appointment. Costco is not a dedicated tire store because of the long lines.

When it comes to customer service and comments, both Costco and Discount Tires have received mixed ratings. Consumer Affairs currently gives Costco Tire Centre a 3.8/5 score.

Costco's installation personnel broke a wheel nut and refused to fix or replace it, according to the most helpful review. Scary!

Discount Tire, with a rating of just over 3.7/5, fared a little behind. Discount Tires is outstanding at what it does – providing cheap tires, according to the most helpful review. And it shouldn't be graded on things it doesn't provide, like wheel alignment, detailing, or checking and changing your oil.

Discount Tire is the winner in this area. Even for an emergency repair, customer care is outstanding and responds quickly. To meet road hazards or flat tire concerns, the inexpensive tire has various shop repair outlets located around the country.

6. Trade-in Options

Discount Tire will not purchase your used tires, but you may be able to trade them in when purchasing new tires. This amount will be applied as a credit toward the total cost of your new tires.

It's unclear how much of a credit you'll get because it relies on several factors, including the age, manufacturer, type, and tread of your tires.

Furthermore, most credits are typically minor, so don't expect to obtain your brand-new tires for half the price.

The best thing you can do is visit your local Discount Tire store so they can check for themselves how bad your tires are.

In any case, they'll have to be inspected. However, if you want to know what amount of credit you'll get so you can best budget for your new tires, contact ahead to book an appointment to have them look at your current tires.

Costco does not appear to have a trade-in program. This is most likely because they do not sell used tires, but Discount Tire does.

Furthermore, Costco's system is set up in such a way that any tire with a DOT date older than two years is not accepted.

7. Maintenance and Repair Service

Emergency repair service is readily available at Discount Tire. Aside from that, the company provides free tire repair regardless of the tire source. Costco Tire has a professional team that bills consumers for repair services that aren't covered by the warranty.

Repairs and maintenance are not handled by Costco. Premium members, on the other hand, can take advantage of service center savings. Employees of Costco are solely responsible for their company's tires. Discount Tire is the winner in this area. You can just drive to any store and request a repair service without having to spend anything.

However, things are a little different when it comes to maintenance. Tires are prone to deterioration if they are used frequently. This is especially true if you frequently drive in difficult terrains, such as off-road situations. It's critical to think about what the seller offers in terms of maintenance support.

Costco has several advantages over Discount Tire, including free lifetime maintenance. This is a great approach to cut down on the long-term cost of tire ownership while keeping it in top shape. The following are some of the free services that come with this incentive:

  • Tire rotations
  • Tire balancing for lifetime
  • Flat repairs
  • Lifetime checks for inflation pressure

You get more value out of each tire with these complimentary services. While the average cost is higher than Discount Tire, the lifelong services you will be qualified for make it worth every penny.

8. Appointment

Because most of us are busy, having the ability to book an appointment for services such as tire installation and maintenance is beneficial. You will not have to wait in line and will be able to arrive on time.

You can make an appointment with Discount Tire or Costco, whichever you want. It's possible to do it online or over the phone. However, the acceptable schedule will be determined by the dealership you visit.

9. Shipping

You can have the tires mailed instead of making an appointment for a physical visit if you don't want to make one. This is advantageous if you intend to install them yourself or have them assembled by a local mechanic.

In two to three days, Discount Tire will dispatch your order. However, it is contingent on your location and the proximity of a distribution facility. However, the shipping time with Costco can take anywhere from five to ten days so you should be prepared to wait.

10. Membership

Another significant distinction between Costco and Discount Tire is the requirement for membership. Before purchasing a tire and taking advantage of the complimentary services at Costco, you must first become a member. The good news is that the savings on tires will be more than enough to cover the membership fee.

There is no requirement for a membership with Discount Tire. You don't need to show proof of membership to shop in any store or make an online purchase.

Discount Tire vs Costco: Pros and Cons

Costco and Discount Tire both have their benefits and drawbacks. The best approach is to try each one independently and pick the one that meets all of your requirements. The advantages and disadvantages of each are listed below.

Pros of Discount Tires

  • Regardless of the source, provide free tire repair service
  • Affordable tires
  • The number of tire brands available is unlimited
  • Great customer support

Cons of Discount Tires

  • Fill tires with compressed air
  • There are hidden costs

Pros of Costco

  • Free tire rotation and balancing services are available
  • Free pressure and inflation checks are available
  • Nitrogen is filled in the tires

Cons of Costco

  • Tire brands are limited
  • Very expensive

How to Choose the Right Tire

Whether you buy from Discount Tire or Costco, there are some critical things you need to keep in mind to choose the right tire for your vehicle. The following are the most essential considerations when selecting a tire for your car.

Type of Tire

One of the most significant considerations is to select a type that is appropriate for the driving conditions, such as the terrain on which you will be riding. Here are a few options.


It's a great choice for wet weather driving because it contains silica-enriched treads, which provide superior traction and a higher speed rating.


It's an all-season tire that's noted for its adaptability, as the name suggests. In a variety of circumstances, it provides great handling and comfort.


This is a great tire to use for driving in dry conditions. It is only suitable for use in warm weather.


This is one of the most popular specialty tires on the market. The design has been tweaked for optimum snow performance.


It is also responsible for providing more responsive handling, in addition to all-season traction. Furthermore, it has a higher speed rating than all-season tires.


It is the greatest option for those looking for extreme tread patterns on their tires. If you enjoy off-road driving, this is the vehicle for you.


Select the appropriate size, ensuring that it is suitable for your car. Choosing something larger or smaller than what is required will have serious consequences, particularly in terms of safety and performance. The size of the tire can be determined by looking at the sidewall.

Choosing the right tire size can be difficult, especially if you're upgrading from your vehicle's original equipment size.

The primary criterion for a tire is that it can handle the weight of your vehicle. If a tire's capacities are "overworked" just supporting the load, it will have little reserve capacity to assist your vehicle in responding to a sudden emergency. As a result, make sure that the size of your new tire is built to carry the weight of your vehicle when you're making your selection! Don't skimp on the size.

The entire tire diameter is another size factor. Because many of today's automobiles' functions are heavily computerized, proper speed data entering the computer ensures accurate instructions coming out. The overall tire diameter is also a significant aspect of the speed equation.

For vehicles and vans, a diameter change of less than 3% is desirable. Pickup trucks and sport utility vehicles (SUVs) are typically designed to accommodate up to a 15% oversize tire. The majority of tire dimensions are calculable.

While a 3 percent diameter rise or reduction in tire diameter may appear to be restrictive at first, in most circumstances it allows for a 3/4" diameter shaft.

A technique is known as "Plus Sizing" was also established to aid in the choosing of substitute sizes. We employ Plus Sizing to consider the diameters of the available tires and wheels before recommending the tire width that will provide suitable load capacity. Preserving the overall diameter of the tire aids in maintaining accurate speed data entering the computer.


Examine the load rating of the tire, which specifies the maximum weight it can support. The speed rating, on the other hand, represents the maximum speed at which the tire can travel while remaining safe and operating well. Make sure the ratings correspond to your car. This information can be found on the sidewall.

Custom Tire Options

Is your vehicle one-of-a-kind? The specific type of tires can often be used to highlight paint jobs, chrome embellishments, tinted windows, and bespoke exhausts. Low-profile tires are popular among custom vehicle drivers.

If you ride an antique or classic car, you may wish to select historically correct tires. When it comes to personalizing your vehicle, you must choose a tire that is appropriate for your driving style. Off-road tires are ideal for heavy-duty tasks, whereas performance tires are designed to accelerate.

There are various styles to pick from if you want to make a statement with your tires. If you want something classic, whitewalls might be the way to go. These tires are frequently seen on older automobiles. If you want to make a statement, a pair of chrome rims with white lettering might be the way to go.

When it comes to choosing tires, most drivers want to make a statement. You will never be bored with the appearance of your vehicle if you choose a style of tire that matches your personality. The sky is the limit when it comes to tire selections!

Driving Conditions

Almost any tire will suffice if you simply drive about your neighborhood and a "long trip" involves a trip to the corner convenience store. However, if you drive during rush hour on busy city streets and expressways, you'll benefit from more responsive tires.

If you drive a lot on the interstates, you'll want tires that are quiet, smooth, and long-lasting. Alternatively, if you enjoy driving swiftly on winding roads or across the mountains, you will require superb handling tires. You'll also want the greatest competition tires if you ride on the circuit or in autocross events.

If your worst and normal driving conditions are identical, you'll only need one pair of tires. If you live on the outskirts of the Snowbelt and don't receive much snow, you might want to go with an all-season tire. Incredibly aggressive commercial vehicle tires aren't for you if your SUV serves as the family's station wagon and is constantly driven on the road.

If your worst driving situation occurs frequently (you drive through snow all winter), you might want to consider buying two sets of tires for your car. Each set will be tailored to conquer the conditions at hand without jeopardizing driving enjoyment at the extremes.

While buying two sets of tires may appear to be costly, the set you're not using will not wear while the other set is in use, and the two sets together will provide more overall wear than either pair could provide individually.

Discount Tire vs Costco: Which Is Better Overall

Tires are necessary, and as a driver, you require the greatest brand and services available. As a result, be cautious while selecting a retailer. And, of course, conduct thorough research.

By now, you know that Costco and Discount Tire are superior in their own right. Discount Tire should be your first stop if you are looking for a variety of brands. Costco, on the other hand, is the place to go if you want privileges like pressure and inflation checks.

Costco and Discount Tires are also fantastic options to explore. Both include free flat tire repair, balance, and rotation. Tire prices are usually in line with their value and driving performance. However, Discount tire service is speedier than Costco tire service. Without an appointment, the former provides urgent repair services such as road hazards.

When it comes to covering road hazards, Costco Tire has no hidden fees. Customers who buy discount tires must pay an additional charge for a certificate that serves as a road hazard warranty. Costco tire is a good option if you want high-quality services. Discount Tire is suitable for those who are on a tight budget.

Discount Tire Vs Costco

About The Author

Charles Redding

Charles Redding

I've spent many years selling cars, working with auto detailers, mechanics, dealership service teams, quoting and researching car insurance, modding my own cars, and much more.

Read More About Charles Redding