The Hidden Downside To Choosing Diesel Engines For City Driving

Diesel engines are great for big trucks or fuel-efficient cars, but they aren’t always the best option. There are some downsides to driving diesel in the city.

Key Takeaways

  • Diesel engines offer several benefits but may not be suited for short, city commutes.
  • Driving a diesel in the city can lead to maintenance issues and environmental concerns.
  • Careful consideration is needed to determine if the advantages outweigh the risks.

Diesel engines are great for big trucks or fuel-efficient cars, but they aren’t always the best option. There are some downsides to driving diesel in the city.

Some of the biggest downsides to driving a diesel vehicle in the city are:

  • Environmental impact
  • Fuel inefficiencies on short drives
  • Variable diesel fuel cost
  • Not enough time for the engine to heat up
  • Regulatory concerns
  • Clogging the particulate filter
  • Expensive purchase for city driving

The goal of this site is to provide our readers with the most helpful and informational content that we can. To do that, we combine our own automotive knowledge and expertise with thorough research and anecdotal information from other auto experts and people passionate about the industry. After vetting everything we come up with for accuracy, we share it with you and you can rest assured knowing you’re getting the best info on the web.

Table of Contents

Downsides of Driving Diesel Vehicles in the City

When considering a diesel-powered vehicle for city driving, it's crucial to weigh specific drawbacks, such as environmental concerns, fuel inefficiency for the urban context, cost fluctuations, and more.

Environmental Impact

The environmental repercussions of operating a diesel engine in the city are significant. Diesel engines emit nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM), which can contribute to smog and poor air quality, impacting public health. Your drive through the city, with its stop-and-go traffic, can exacerbate these emissions due to the constant idling and acceleration.

One problem is that diesel engines tend to run cooler in city traffic and never reach the optimal temperatures required to efficiently burn off harmful pollutants. This leads to higher concentrations of these contaminants in urban areas. Your choice of a diesel car can affect air quality more than you might realize.

Furthermore, cities often have a dense population exposed to these emissions, raising the risk of respiratory issues like asthma. European cities have started to recognize this risk, with some banning older diesel vehicles from city centers to reduce pollution. If you live in a densely populated area, the emissions from your diesel engine might be affecting not only your health but also that of your fellow citizens.

It is also crucial to consider the impact of diesel emissions on the greenhouse effect and climate change. Although diesel vehicles can be more CO2 efficient than their petrol counterparts on the highway, frequent short trips and traffic jams in the city decrease this advantage, leading to higher overall emissions.

Fuel Inefficiencies Compared to Highway Driving

Despite diesel engines being known for their fuel efficiency, city driving changes the equation. Diesel engines achieve optimal fuel efficiency under consistent loads, such as on highways. However, in the city context, you're often dealing with traffic lights, stop signs, and congestion. This stop-and-go pattern doesn't allow your diesel vehicle to maintain steady speeds where it's most fuel-efficient.

Diesel engines rely on a high level of compression to ignite the fuel, making them less suited for short trips that are typical in city driving. Frequent starting and stopping prevent the engine from warming up properly, which means your diesel vehicle is often running under less-than-ideal conditions, reducing its fuel efficiency advantage.

Moreover, because city driving does not allow the diesel engine to operate consistently at peak efficiency, you end up consuming more fuel than you would on the highway for the same distance. This increased fuel usage negates one of the primary benefits of opting for a diesel engine and may result in higher running costs for city dwellers.

Fuel Cost Variability

The price of diesel fuel can be a downside. While it is often praised for its mpg efficiency, the cost of diesel fluctuates and, in some cases, is more expensive than gasoline. This variability means that your fuel budget can be unpredictable.

In many regions, diesel prices also react to different factors than gasoline, including the seasonal demand for heating oil (which diesel is closely related to) and international events since diesel is more widely used globally. Your city commutes may become costlier at times when diesel prices surge.

Moreover, any savings gained from diesel's fuel efficiency can be wiped out by its higher price. Cities with frequent diesel price fluctuations may therefore significantly affect your cost of ownership.

Diesel Engines Need Time to Heat Up

Diesel engines are designed to reach a certain operating temperature for optimal performance and efficiency. They need time to warm up, especially in colder climates. In city driving, your engine may never reach this optimal temperature when you are making short trips or idling in traffic. This can result in your vehicle running less efficiently, increasing fuel consumption. Prolonged periods of running cold can also cause engine wear and tear over time.

Furthermore, not allowing your diesel engine to fully warm up before shutting it off can lead to incomplete combustion, which would not be as problematic on longer drives where the engine has sufficient time to reach and maintain its intended temperature.

Easier to Clog the Particulate Filter On Short Drives

Diesel Particulate Filters (DPFs) are necessary to capture and contain soot emissions. However, frequent short journeys in the city can lead to the DPF not reaching the required temperature to 'regenerate' – this is when the soot is burnt off at high temperatures.

In city driving, you're more likely to clog up the particulate filter because of the lower engine temperatures and lack of prolonged high-speed operation. This can result in expensive maintenance or repair costs as the DPF needs to be cleaned or replaced more frequently than if the vehicle were driven longer distances.

Additionally, a clogged DPF can decrease your engine's performance and fuel economy, making your city drive less smooth and more costly. It also poses the risk of you not meeting emissions standards, which is increasingly important in urban areas with stricter environmental regulations.

Potential Regulatory Issues

Cities around the world are getting tougher on diesel vehicles due to the pollutants they emit. Many urban areas are introducing Low Emission Zones (LEZs) or even banning older diesel engines entirely.

As a diesel vehicle owner in the city, you might face certain restrictions or additional charges that gasoline vehicle owners do not. These measures could limit your access to certain parts of the city or lead to unexpected costs.

The trend towards tightening emission standards could also potentially result in a lower resale value for your diesel vehicle. Considering the long-term outlook, you might find your diesel car harder to sell or trade in if you're in an area with such regulations.

Diesel Vehicles are Typically More Expensive Upfront

When purchasing a vehicle, you'll often find that diesel models come with a higher price tag compared to their gasoline counterparts. This is attributed to the more robust construction needed to withstand the high compression ratios of diesel engines.

The initial cost means that you must drive more miles to recoup the investment through fuel savings. In city conditions, where short trips are more common and fuel efficiency benefits are diminished, it can take much longer to break even.

Also, while diesel engines may last longer and have lower maintenance costs in the long run, the upfront cost is something that you need to consider. It might be a substantial factor, especially if your budget is a concern or if you're not planning on keeping the vehicle for an extended time.

In summary, owning a diesel vehicle in the city can present a unique set of challenges. It's worth considering these factors carefully to ensure the most informed decision for your urban driving needs.


Charles Redding

Charles Redding

I've spent many years selling cars, working with auto detailers, mechanics, dealership service teams, quoting and researching car insurance, modding my own cars, and much more.

Read More About Charles Redding